Renovate or Move? How to Decide When Your Home No Longer Fits
Unsure whether to renovate or move? Explore the costs, lifestyle considerations, and long-term benefits of each option to make the right decision.

If you love your location and the house can be renovated, usually renovating will be a good option. However, if the issue is with the location/lot it is often better to move. If you just need more space then an addition could be a good option.
Think about what issues there are with your home, how attached you are to the location, total costs and how long you plan to stay. Renovating will allow you to stay within your neighbourhood, have a good mortgage rate and you’ll have some construction to go through. Whereas moving can provide a better layout/location, however you’ll have to pay to sell and buy a property and take on a new mortgage.
When is Renovation a Good Option?
Generally if your kitchen looks outdated, your main bathroom is small and your finishes are old you can renovate. If you love your location and the renovations can be done within your home and/or lot then a well-planned renovation will provide you with the home you want with less disruption.
If you want to stay within your neighbourhood, schools or commute, have a better mortgage rate and the home is structurally sound with space in the lot and a good layout to improve then renovation is a good option.
If you plan on staying for many years you will have time to enjoy the renovation.
You can do certain areas of the renovation such as the kitchen, bathroom or open up the main floor.
When is Moving a Better Option?
If the issue is with location/lot then moving can be a good option. Renovation won’t help with shortening your commute, changing school zones or giving you more land. If the renovation would cost almost as much as buying a home that suits your needs, or would leave you a house that is worth much more than the surrounding homes then moving may be a good option.
You may not have space to live on one floor due to stairs throughout the home, not have enough space in the lot to build an addition. There maybe local regulations stopping you making the changes you need. If you don’t want to live through months of construction then this is something to think about.
How Much Will Moving Cost?
Think about the total costs involved. Whilst the contractors quote and asking price may seem like the only costs, there are more.
Cost | Renovation | Relocation |
Main Cost | Contractor | Price difference between homes |
Fees | Designing and permits | Selling fees, closing costs and new loan |
Living Costs | Maybe rent whilst doing major works | Moving costs, double costs |
Mortgage | Current rate | New loan at current rate |
Time | Weeks/Months | Listing, selling, buying and moving |
This will all depend on your home and local market. Ask a local agent how much your home would likely sell for and how much a suitable home would cost. Ask a contractor how much it would cost to do the work needed.
Is Renovation Cheaper Than Buying Another Home?
Generally renovations to your kitchen/bathroom are cheaper due to not having to pay any selling fees, closing costs or new loan. However, if you are renovating your entire home the cost can be similar. If most of the rooms are being rebuilt, with moving walls and replacing systems it can be similar to a home that would suit your needs.
For example, in Columbia, MO Spillman Homes have full kitchen renovations from $80,000 and bathrooms from $30,000. If these are the only areas you need then compare this to the selling and buying costs. However, if every room needs doing then you are looking at a much bigger renovation.
How to Start Renovating Your Home
Write down a list of issues with your home.
Write down what issues need fixing. For example, not enough storage, kitchen not working for your family or only one bathroom for four people.
Prioritise them based on how much they are affecting your daily life.
Decide on a budget range you are happy with, remembering to include some for unexpected costs.
Speak to a contractor who provides designing.
Ask how much it will cost, will it be a fixed price once the design is done or will it be cost plus. How will any changes be approved?
Plan where you will be living whilst your kitchen/only bathroom is out of use.
Generally you can expect a kitchen renovation to take 6-12 weeks once the design is complete and materials have been ordered. Whereas bathrooms can take 3-6 weeks. A full renovation will generally take 3-6 months. Try to think about how long it will take as much as how much it will cost.
When is Adding onto Your Home a Better Option?
If you love your location but just need more space then adding onto your home is worth getting a price for. Depending how big your lot is and any local regulations you may be able to add a main suite, extend your kitchen, create a home office or add a bedroom for your growing family. Often adding on can be cheaper and less disruptive.
Adding onto your home is more involved than renovating as you will need a new foundation, permits and connect to your existing roof. Often you will need to replace your heating and cooling systems. Find out what the setback requirements and lot coverage requirements are for your city/county. Speak to a contractor to see if the structure and systems can support the extra space.
How to Decide Between Renovation and Relocation
Think about what you want to renovate and compare it to what you would buy. Think about how big the renovation would be, how much it would cost and how long it would take compared to how much the home would cost and total costs of relocation.
Try to get both quotes. By having a walk through with a contractor who provides designing you will get the most accurate price for your renovation (usually guessed by most homeowners). Whether it is a few rooms or a full renovation, Spillman Homes in Mid-Missouri will start planning for a full renovation and agree a price once the scope has been agreed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I Renovate or Move Due to My Low Mortgage Rate?
If you love your location then you should try to renovate as you’ll have a low mortgage rate. Moving would mean taking on a new loan at the current rate.
Is Renovation Cheaper Than Moving?
Generally yes, especially if renovating the kitchen/bathroom. However if most of the home is being renovated it will be closer in price.
How Long Does a Full Renovation Take?
Generally 3-6 months once the design has been completed and materials ordered. Kitchens usually take 6-12 weeks.
Can I Stay in My Home During Renovation?
Yes, generally you can whilst doing 1-2 rooms. However if you are doing a full renovation or your kitchen/bathroom is the only one then you will often need somewhere else to stay.
When is Adding Onto My Home a Better Option?
If you need more space and have space in your lot you can add onto your home. This means you can stay in your location without paying any moving costs.
Should I Renovate Before Selling?
Keep the renovation to minor changes to help you sell. Spend your larger budget on the home you will be living in, whether this is your current home post-renovation or another home that suits your household.




Comments